Oh My God!! Dee Valladares may already be the most dangerous player on the board — fans are in shock!
With one crucial move, Dee Valladares has quietly positioned herself with power that could shape the endgame of Survivor 50 more than some of the remaining castaways understand.
Over time, fans have nicknamed the first juror the “Mayor of Ponderosa” because that person helps set the tone for everything that happens between elimination and the finale. And in a season as unpredictable as Survivor 50, that role may carry more influence than the players still in the game realize.
Not only does the first juror get the most time to emotionally detach from the game, but they also have the longest runway to campaign for the contestant they want to win. So when Dee Valladares landed that key position, it may have come at the expense of several other players’ chances.
Looking at the numbers, the first juror has been part of the majority winning vote 83.67% of the time across the last 49 seasons. Only eight seasons ended with the person in that first jury seat backing a finalist who did not ultimately win:
- Survivor: Thailand (Erin Collins voted for Clay Jordan, but Brian Heidik won)
- Survivor: Palau (Coby Archa voted for Katie Gallagher, but Tom Westman won)
- Survivor: Nicaragua (Alina Wilson voted for Chase Rice, but Jud “Fabio” Birza won)
- Survivor: Philippines (RC Saint-Amour voted for Lissa Whelchel, but Denise Stapley won)
- Survivor: Kaoh Rong (Nick Maiorano voted for Aubry Bracco, but Michele Fitzgerald won)
- Survivor: Ghost Island (Chris Noble voted for Domenick Abbate, but Wendell Holland won)
- Survivor 46 (Soda Thompson voted for Charlie Davis, but Kenzie Petty won)
- Survivor 48 (Cedrek McFadden voted for Joe Hunter, but Kyle Fraser won)
While it is impossible to prove the first juror directly controls the final vote — especially because the winner usually played a strong enough game to deserve the title of Sole Survivor — the consistency is hard to ignore. And with Dee serving as the Survivor 50 Mayor of Ponderosa, there may be some players who simply cannot win if they reach the end. One of them could be Jonathan Young, whom Dee saw up close playing a weak game before her elimination.
That makes Jonathan an interesting option for the players still left. He may be worth taking to the Final Tribal Council if Dee is already against him and if he lacks the résumé to win her over. Even with former allies Chrissy Hofbeck and Coach Wade on the jury — both of whom could support him if they are willing to stay loyal to the “honor and integrity” alliance — there is no question that Christian Hubicki would not reward a player who failed to impress. After all, he once voted against his closest ally in favor of Mike White at the end of Survivor: David vs. Goliath.
And while Stephenie LaGrossa Kendrick may look ready to hold a grudge after her exit this week — which could be a bonus for Jonathan at the finale — her history on the Survivor: Palau jury shows she ultimately values crowning someone who truly deserves the win.
As castaways keep getting their torches snuffed by Jeff Probst week after week, the real question is whether Dee’s influence will reach them and affect the ending of the game. With the jury growing and the remaining players still fighting for position, there is strong potential for a razor-close Final Tribal Council, especially as everyone starts making their biggest moves.
For more SURIVIVOR updates, follow Daily News.
Come back here often for Survivor spoilers, news and updates.
