“Suddenly Amish” is the latest entry in the realm of Amish-themed reality TV, alongside predecessors such as “Amish Mafia” and “Breaking Amish”. But don’t get your hopes too high, as the nature of these shows can be quite… peculiar.
Upon diving into my own viewing of this show, I finally uncovered the quirks that make it a fascinating spectacle. Here are six of the most outrageous elements witnessed in Episode One.
1. Bishop Vernon’s “Day of Reckoning” Setup
The premise revolves around Bishop Vernon, who claims newbies have just one month to prove themselves. Allen is tasked with preparing them for the “day of reckoning” — a dramatic climax where decisions about their Amish journey are made.
However, this notion of a month’s trial does not reflect the long adjustment period truly required to adapt to Amish life.
2. Treating the Amish as Mainly a “Lifestyle” Group
Dialogue from the English cast frequently highlights lifestyle choices rather than the roots of Amish faith, blurring the lines between cultural appreciation and misunderstanding.
This show seems to trivialize being Amish, as it’s portrayed more as a fad than a genuine spiritual commitment.
3. The Outhouse Caper
Billie Jo’s visit to an outhouse raises eyebrows. Allen hands her a newspaper, explaining this is the Amish substitute for toilet paper, despite the fact that most Amish have indoor plumbing.
4. Kendra’s Shaming
Kendra is swiftly reprimanded for her clothing choices by Bishop Vernon, raising questions about whether she genuinely lacks knowledge of Amish values.
5. James’ Quarantining of the Outsiders’ Baggage
James, who is shunned by his community, insists outsiders leave their bags outside, preventing “contamination” from worldly possessions.
6. Esmerelda’s Fake Nails Conflict
In a baffling standoff, Esmerelda defies Allen’s insistence that she remove her fake nails, despite earlier claims about her interest in Amish traditions.
Treat it as Entertainment
This show is not an accurate portrayal of real Amish life; it serves mainly as entertainment. It blurs the line between misconceptions and exaggerations that entertain a mass audience.
Despite the overwhelming absurdity, there are likable characters on the show, and the concept of self-improvement resonates within its chaotic framework.
Given that four episodes have aired already, viewers may wonder what directions the show may take. With a season still ongoing, stay tuned as we explore more of the wild antics of “Suddenly Amish”!
